Music History Paper Number 2!
Filed under: Music, Uncategorized
Music History III
Dr. Carson
2nd Research Paper
Matt Wheeler
Who Stands Out?
From the Second Half of the 20th Century and Beyond
The second half of the twentieth century was, in many ways, quite different from the fifty years that preceded it. Like large roots coming out of a tree, the musical developments of the first half of the twentieth century were mostly children or grandchildren of Mahler, Wagner, Strauss and other late romantic ‘greats’. Influence is easy to trace. The stand-outs like Stravinsky, Copland and Schoenberg all had a clear lineage and an impressive effect on the outcome of music to follow. With the back half of the twentieth century, and beyond, however, it becomes more and more difficult to make clear judgments of importance based solely on musical heritage and musical descendants. Like some twisted version of Pascal’s triangle where most every element is connected to another, so are the musicians of our recent times. In addition to the standard of ‘influential’ becoming less defined, we simply have had less time to make accurate judgments of who is deemed ‘influential’. History hasn’t weeded out the composers and musicians who will soon be forgotten, leaving only the Bachs and the Beethovens of our generation. This only strengthens the importance of a few people who can definitely be pointed towards as influential in the second half of the twentieth century: Leonard Bernstein, Nadia Boulanger and John Williams.
Leonard Bernstein’s role in shaping American music was quite pronounced. He involved himself in many different areas of music propagation – teaching, performing, conducting, broadcasting, recording, composing, writing. In his obituary in the NY times, Bernstein was called the “renaissance man of American music.” (1) It is clearly seen by the many different roles he had over the years. The one for which he will most be remembered is as conductor of the New York Philharmonic. However, he was also an international force, conducting the Israel Philharmonic, the Vienna Philharmonic, the Berlin Philharmonic and the London Symphony Orchestra to name a few. He recorded prolific amounts of records with many of these orchestras, and they stand among the definitive recordings of our day. As a conductor, he used his position of influence to promote the works of Charles Ives and Carl Nielsen, both of whom were not well known to the American public, and also resurrected the works of Mahler. He influenced young conductors, including Seiji Ozawa, who was an assistant to Bernstein and made his television debut on Bernstein’s Young People’s Concerts. This nationally televised series was most beloved by American audiences, and featured “Lenny” engaging audiences of all ages and instilling within them a love for all things music. There were fifty-three broadcasts from 1958 to 1972, unprecedented, and their likes have not been seen again. Jamie Bernstein, eldest daughter of Leonard, wrote “I can’t tell you how many people come up to me now, everywhere I go in the States, and they say something like: ‘Oh, I used to watch your father’s Young People’s Concerts on TV, and I’ve been a music lover ever since!’ And an equally large number of orchestra musicians come up to me and say, “I watched the Young People’s Concerts when I was a kid, and that’s why I’m a musician today!” (2) That is a legacy of significance, and it was recognized in Bernstein’s own time, even as it was being laid. In an article in the New York Tribune, the author praised the young Bernstein for his innovative and impacting television series, saying, “One great teacher bursting with vitality and personality and information could spread his culture all over the country, assaulting you in a physical wave to such a degree that a short course in opera sticks in a million or so craniums forevermore. It’s quite a feat if you can bring it off and Bernstein can and does… He’s a natural asset, that young man, and one we should treasure.” (3) America did treasure Lenny, for his conducting, teaching and his composing. As a composer, Bernstein wrote many memorable pieces, standards of the twentieth century literature, among them, West Side Story, a musical that changed the future of the American musical. John Chapman, in his review in the New York Times wrote that West Side Story “takes up the American musical idiom where it was left when George Gershwin died.” (4) Music Critic Peter Gutmann continues further, pronouncing West Side Story as “the great American musical.” (5) In all of his roles, teacher, conductor, television personality, recording artist, composer, Bernstein considered himself to be a student first and foremost, one who loved to learn and pass on what he discovered. That was what drove him, and the result was a man of great musical influence in the second half of the twentieth century.
Nadia Boulanger’s sphere of influence stands in stark contrast to Leonard Bernstein’s legacy. Where Bernstein was diverse in his areas of impact, Boulanger’s focus was on one area – pedagogy. The amount of power this lady wielded over the shape and direction of twentieth century music is almost magical. And while her career of influence began before the second half of the twentieth century, and a good many of her more well known students studied with her before 1950, both Boulanger’s and her students’ careers continued into the second half, and their range influence is still felt today. “So far as musical pedagogy is concerned, and by extension of musical creation, Nadia Boulanger is the most influential person who ever lived.” (6) These were the words of Pulitzer Prize and Grammy Award winning Ned Rorem, respected composer and song writer, and once upon a time, a student of Boulanger. Her effect is more quantitative than qualitative. She taught and untold number of students from around the world. More than 600 American students studied under her during her lifetime. Her residence in Paris was a primary reason why the city was the musical center of the world for so long. Don Campbell, author of Master Teacher: Nadia Boulanger, wrote, “I have continued to be astonished at her penetrating and far reaching influence on music today… Nadia Boulanger and her remarkable lifetime of 93 years still can direct students of future generations to the remarkable pedagogy necessary for skill development and brilliance in this century…” (7) Through Boulanger’s students and countless numbers of grand-and-great-grand-students, her legacy lives on. Listed below are a selection of her students and a brief summary of their accomplishments or important compositions.
- George Antheil – composer of Ballet Mecanique
- Marc Blitzstein – composer, adapted Kurt Weill’s Three Penny Opera into English
- Elliot Carter – composer, teacher
- Aaron Copland – composer, known for creating ‘American’ style
- David Diamond – composer, teacher at Julliard
- George Gershwin – composer of Rahpsody in Blue, Porgy and Bess
- Quincy Jones – music producer, nominated record 79 times for Grammy Awards
- Douglas Moore – composer of Ballad of Baby Doe
- Gian Carlo Menotti – composer of Ahmal and Night Visitors
- Philip Glass – minimalist and film composer
- Astor Piazzolla – reviver of the tango
- Walter Piston – composer and music theorist
- Ned Rorem – art song composer
- Laurence Rosenthal – film composer
- Roger Sessions – composer, teacher
- Virgil Thomson – composer of Four Saints in Three Acts
It was Virgil Thomson who had this insightful, if exaggerated and humorous quote about Boulanger. “She was a one-woman graduate school, so powerful and so permeating that legend credits every United States town with two things: a five-and-dime and a Boulanger pupil.” (8) While the five-and-dimes have faded with their time, Boulanger’s impression on music in the second half of the twentieth century has been unmistakable and lasting.
John Williams, like Nadia Boulanger, has had an area of influence much more restricted than Leonard Bernstein. Known for his film scores, which number over one hundred, John Williams is one of the few modern day composers who could be called a household name. His influence certainly lies in his more universal fame, and also in the impact he has had on the film music industry. His scores display a remarkable variety in stylistic influence, ranging from the motif based horror film scores like JAWS and The Fury, to the full fanfare sounds of Star Wars and Indiana Jones series, to the jazzy moods of Sabrina and Catch Me If You Can, to the Asian-influenced Seven Years in Tibet and Memoirs of a Geisha. John Williams has turned this stylistic influence around and made it into an influence of his own. “The scores of John Williams, from the perspective of orchestral music-lovers and his fellow peers, have changed the course of film music history.” (9) At a time when the orchestral score was becoming less and less prominent in films, being taken over by pop music of the day, John Williams was approached by George Lucas and asked to write a musical score in the grand symphonic style of past giants Max Steiner and Eric Wolfgang Korngold. The result was the film score for Star Wars. In 2005, the American Film Institute compiled a list of the top 25 film scores of all time. “A jury of over 500 film artists, composers, musicians, critics and historians selected John Williams’ iconic score from the classic film STAR WARS as the most memorable film score of all time. John Williams is additionally noteworthy as the most represented composer on the list with three scores making the top 25.” (10) Full of Wagernerian leit-motif, Williams re-inspired a more classically based genre of film scores. Influences nowadays include James Newton Howard, Alexandre Desplat, Dario Marianelli, James Horner, Edward Shearmur and Patrick Doyle, just a few of the composers who prescribe to the orchestral, classical, theme and motive based concept of the film score. “Williams is undoubtedly one of the most respected composers for Cinema.” His fame and influence within the world of the film composer is renown. But, there is also a more universal and nostalgic side to his influence. His music from Jurassic Park is both found in fifth grade band books and performed as popular concert repertoire. The opening credits fanfare is hummed by every kid who grows up loving the Star Wars series and reenacts the scenes with his or her buddies. Two low notes, a half step apart, given that rhythmic thrum are instantly recognizable as the iconic theme from JAWS. His music is pervasive in our culture, and thus his influence is everywhere. “John Williams is as easy to recall as John Philip Sousa, Aaron Copland or Leonard Bernstein, illustrating why he is “America’s composer” time and again.” (11) Some might view this as a highly controversial statement. But, when it comes down to it, of all the American living composers, the everyday American is more likely to whistle John Williams than John Cage.
Influence in the second half of the twentieth century is more difficult to trace or define or agree on. Indeed, only time will truly be able to tell who is worthy of being truly influential. Given time, a great many of our modern day musicians, pop stars and classical greats alike will fade into the memory of the not so distant past. Nadia Boulanger, though, will not be one of them. Her place in history is already as firmly entrenched as her students’ like Copland, Gershwin and Virgil Thomson. The effect she had on the more than 600 American students will ripple on through future generations of musicians as an unstoppable force, truly making her an influential musician of the Twentieth Century and Beyond.
1. Donal Henahan. Obituary. New York Times. Oct. 15, 1990.
2. Jamie Bernstein. Leonard Bernstein, the Educator. http://www.leonardbernstein.com/educator.htm
3. New York Herald Tribune, quoted by Peter Gutmann. http://www.classicalnotes.net/features/bernstein.html
4. John Chapman. New York Daily News. Sept. 27, 1957.
5. Peter Gutmann. http://www.classicalnotes.net/features/bernstein.html
6. Ned Rorem. http://www.nadiaboulanger.org/
7. Don Campbell. Ibid.
8. Virgil Thomson. Ibid.
9. http://www.filmtracks.com/composers/williams.shtml
10. http://www.afi.com/tvevents/100years/scores.aspx
11. Jeffrey Wheeler. http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0002354/bio
12. Ibid.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Bernstein, Jamie. Leonard Bernstein, the Educator. http://www.leonardbernstein.com/educator.htm
Chapman, John. New York Daily News, Sept. 27, 1957.
Gutmann, Peter. http://www.classicalnotes.net/features/bernstein.html
Henahan, Donal. Obituary. New York Times, Oct. 15, 1990.
Wheeler, Jeffrey. http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0002354/bio
http://www.afi.com/tvevents/100years/scores.aspx